What plants will survive in my climate zone?
- This is a critical question that comes up all the time.
- Below are the major factors to consider as well as the tools/tips needed to make the right decision.
Most important factor:
- For the vast majority of gardeners, the single most important issue to consider when selecting a plant is its cold tolerance.
- Different plant species have different low temperature survival thresholds.
- Most of the time, this low threshold temperature is known information for a particular plant species.
How low will it go around here?
- The next logical question is, “how low can I expect the temps to go in my area?”
- Well, there’s a map for that… and it’s called the “USDA Plant Hardness Zone Map”
- This is basically a very detailed type of climate zone map (see image below)
Here’s how the map works:
- Identify the color that your home area is given on the map.
- Match up that map-color to the color coded zone-key on the side of the map
- (the second map provided below has better resolution for viewing the zone-key)
- Each particular zone corresponds to a specified “Annual Extreme Minimal Temperature” range.
- This is basically the lowest temperature range that you can expect in your area (on average).
Specific example:
- Lets say you are living just outside of the San Diego city limits, and somewhere near the coast (like me).
- You can see that this area on the map is given a yellow-orange color.
- On the map’s zone-key, (on the side of the map) that color corresponds to zone 10a.
- Just to the left side of that color coded zone-key box you can see that there is a temperature range in Fahrenheit (F) and on the right side is the same temperature range in Celsius (C).
- Therefore we can see that for zone 10a, the lowest average temperature that I can expect in my area (on average) is 30 to 35 F, or -1.1 to 1.7 C… Another words, right around freezing.
- As reference: Since I live in zone 10a, (and all the plants outlined on this website are in my yard), then any of the plants you read about on this website should work in zone 10a. Most of the plants discussed will also do great in many other zones as well. Just reference the temperature section of the specific plant article.
- If your having trouble matching up the map colors to the zone-key on the map, don’t worry, there is another option.
- The USDA has a website where you can just plug in your zip code to get your “Plant Hardiness Zone”
How was this map compiled?
- Lots of temperature measurements were taken during the time frame from 1976 to 2005.
- Those temperatures were averaged together and after careful evaluation a detailed map was created.
- Because of the success of this method, it has been adopted by many other countries.
- The table below has a list of US and European cities with their respective zone.
Potential pitfalls of this map:
- Since the provided temperature values are averages, they only provide part of the picture.
- For example, a geographic area that has wide fluxuations in low temperatures may end up in the same zone as a geographic area with more stable temperatures.
- In addition, the map doesn’t really account for the potential rogue extreme low temperature that might wipe out plants living at the cooler extent of their biological range.
Prepare for a potential unexpected cold snap:
- As a backup, it’s always a good idea to have an extreme cold weather plan and supplies ready for those occasional extra cold days that may damage or kill a cherished plant.
- Protective frost cloth/blanket is a great option to consider.
- The Protec brand of frost plant cover, and the Dalen brand of Harvest Guard Row Cover are pretty similar products. They are both found on amazon and both have very good reviews.
- Its important to make sure the trunk/bottom of the plant is also enclosed in this material. I use use duck tape to make a pillow case- like sac out of the frost cloth material and it works great to cover trees. After the cold has passed, I roll them up and store them for the next season-then just throw them on when needed.
Microclimate:
- Local variation:
- There is usually at least some climate variation within a particular zone.
- Some parts of the world have more environmental variations in a small geographic area than others.
- A lot of this has to do with the terrain, namely the amount of hills, mountains and valleys in a given area.
- Colder areas:
- Cool air is heavy so it tends to sink to sheltered low areas such as valleys and other geographic depressions. Therefore, low areas are more likely to experience a cooler microclimate.
- (You may have notice this happening in your home: it tends to be warmer on the an upper floor than it is on the first/main floor or basement).
- In addition, an area with persistent shade, such as the low-north side of a hill or house will likely be significantly cooler than an adjacent area just a few steps away. Note, winter shadows are longer-bigger than summer shadows due to the low position of the sun on the horizon, and this should be taken into consideration when choosing your planting locations.
- * Take advantage of these cool areas by planting trees that need a chilling period in lower depressions of your yard or in winter shaded areas.
- Cool air is heavy so it tends to sink to sheltered low areas such as valleys and other geographic depressions. Therefore, low areas are more likely to experience a cooler microclimate.
- Warmer areas:
- An area adjacent to a south facing wall, or on the top/sunny side of a hill will be significantly warmer.
- Areas adjacent to large dark solid objects such as boulders, cement buildings and black asphalt will also be warmer. This effect can carry into the night while those objects radiate the heat they absorbed from the sun during the day.
- * Take advantage of these factors by planting the more cold sensitive plants in these warmer parts of your yard.
Other regional growing considerations:
- There are several other big picture issues to consider when determining if a plant will grow in your area.
- Heat tolerance, drought tolerance, soil type preference, sunlight needs, humidity preference, wind tolerance.
- These factors are all important in their own way. However, in my opinion, the cold tolerance issue that we discussed above is the very most important element.
Dr. Osborne,
I have 2 Flordahome Pear trees that I am very concerned about. The leaves are brown and black, and new leaves have the same coloration within a few days of coming out. I try very hard to use only organic products to control problems, and have been using Neem Oil to control Aphids in this case. Am I doing something wrong?
Thank you for you help!
Hi Charlie
Oh no, sorry to hear about that.
There is a significant list of possible problems that would cause brown and black leaves. Do you happen to have any recent pictures of the leaves or the tree? Seeing the leaves might possibly help to determine what the problem is.
Best,
Tom
LEON
looking and your area map for hardiness and freezing and making a decision whether or not to plant my peach trees and cherry trees , well Doc this map and zone table damn near planted my trees for me. little humor but everything was right on.
Thank you much for the info. I live in the Hemet, Lake EL Sinore area and I just recently moved from PHX AZ having a lot of success with tangelos,tangerines, large naval oranges and lime trees “very successful” in the last pass 3 years.
Know I have tried twices to plant Avacadoes “Hass” type and failed. The tree started to show fruit with all of it’s white blossoms then all of a sudden fruit started to fall off with all of the blossoms. HMMM. and the second tree leaves slowly turned black and poof no leaves no tree. I think we shall call that DEAD don’t you think “DOC”.
ok DOCTOR THOMAS OSBORNE THANK YOU SIR.
Hey Leon
Thank you for your note and you are very welcome.
Glad to hear that it was helpful and congrats on your growing success.
Avocados can be really tricky.
They are sensitive to a lot of different things.
They seem to need well-draining soil more than most trees and the roots are very susceptible to the ill-effects of extra damp soil. They are also very sensitive to salts in the soil/our water and this can show up in the form of leaves that look burnt on the ends. The salter the soil/water the more burn you will see. In my opinion, Avocados are so cheap at the stores around here, and they are such fickle trees, that its just not worth the hassle for me to bother with them.
All the best,
Tom
I planted two pine apple guava trees last year
One in the front yard & the anther one in the back yard which is the southren garden
I live in BAGHDAD where temp.goes up to 50 cent in summer
Can this tree stang and live sch hell area
&thank you
Hey Dr. Raid
Good question.
As you suggest, I think Baghdad might be a bit hot for these plants.
In general feijoas (pineapple guava) prefer cool winters and moderate summers that dont go much above 90 deg F (32 deg Celsius). Therefore, I suspect that 122 deg F (50 deg C) will fry them. They also seem to need around 50 hours of cool temps “chilling time” in the winter. Perhaps they would be better for the mountain foot hills.
Best,
Tom
The USDA zone map is a place to start, but the Sunset Magazine 24-zone climate map system for the western states in their “Western Garden Book” addresses the various regional micro climates in much greater detail. Summer heat and humidity (or lack thereof) can be as significant factors as winter cold. The maps are available online at:
https://www.sunsetwesterngardencollection.com/climate-zones/
I’m in the “banana belt” of “zone 23” in Whittier, CA, where my two banana “trees” (‘Dwarf Cavendish’ and ‘Goldfinger’) are in fruit against the south-facing wall of my garage. My next-door neighbors have plumeria, guavas, papayas and bananas as well. (This area was heavy with citrus and avocado groves up though WWII.)
Sunset has expanded their climate-zone concept nationwide with their “Sunset National Garden Book.” I’ve seen both books listed online.
Hi Jeff
That is great info. Thank you so much for sharing. Congrats on your growing success.
Thanks,
Tom